2nd Wife Troubles 33 Court Dates

As Matthew Sims fought to prove his innocence in the judicial system, the notion that the prosecution wouldn't push for a date to try him convinced Sims that he could prove his case based on the discovery evidence given to him by the prosecution. Sims had to file numerous motions, which were objected to many times by the prosecution. Sims was so convinced of proving his innocence that he would ask the assigned judge to hear his case to set trial dates, but the prosecution kept asking for a stay or delay, perhaps in an effort to frustrate Sims. After four years of back and forth covering 33 court appearances, the judge set May 20, 2024, as the day Sims would get to meet his accuser and those officers who played a role in his arrest, where he was facing felony charges. Sims was ready to proceed.

On the day the trial was supposed to begin, the prosecution again tried to use a delay tactic, trying to get Sims to agree to their request. Still, Sims was determined to have his day in court, as he had police officers to testify to the matter from the night of the arrest. The prosecution elected not to call police officers on their behalf, nor did the "star witness," Sims' ex-fiancé, show up for the prosecution. According to Sims, the prosecution, in effect, didn't have a case to go to trial. The charges were dropped by the prosecution. Finally, after 1,457 days, 47 months, 3 weeks, 207 weeks, 1 day, and 33 court appearances from arrest to dismissal of charges, Sims' life of turmoil in the judicial system came to an end.

Picking up the pieces is difficult for Sims. He has to start all over. He went from a hard-working family man to someone who lost everything. He did many good things for those who were in his life, but that was taken away from him through the words in a police report and the words from an angry woman. Sims says that the process is corrupt; a person’s constitutional rights are violated by a system that can destroy a person's life. As he ponders his next move, Sims says that he wants to leave a legacy of doing something positive for the generations to come: to fight for what is right, especially in trying to clean up the judicial system as many are trying now to do.

There are three sides to every story. This was one side of this story. The Monroe Dispatch welcomes another or the other side of this story.